How Lawyers Handle Insurance Bad Faith Cases

by

Insurance is meant to provide peace of mind and financial protection when unexpected events occur. However, there are times when insurance companies act unfairly or refuse to honor their obligations. This is often referred to as “insurance bad faith.” When policyholders face this kind of treatment, legal recourse can be necessary. Lawyers play a critical role in handling bad faith insurance cases by advocating for the rights of insured individuals or businesses.

This article explains what insurance bad faith means, common examples, and the step-by-step ways lawyers handle these complex cases to secure fair outcomes.

What Is Insurance Bad Faith?

Insurance bad faith occurs when an insurance company unreasonably delays, denies, or underpays a legitimate claim made by a policyholder. Insurance companies have a legal duty to act in good faith and deal fairly with their customers. When they violate this duty, they may be held accountable for bad faith conduct.

Bad faith can be intentional or negligent. Some examples include:

  • Unjustified denial of a valid claim.
  • Unreasonable delays in processing or paying claims.
  • Failure to investigate or evaluate a claim properly.
  • Misrepresenting policy terms to avoid paying.
  • Offering settlements far below what the claim is worth.
  • Ignoring or undervaluing critical evidence.
  • Coercing policyholders into accepting unfair settlements.

Why Are Bad Faith Cases Challenging?

Insurance policies are often complex, with technical language and various conditions. Determining whether an insurer acted in bad faith requires understanding both the legal framework and the specific policy terms. Insurers also have teams of lawyers and adjusters working to protect their interests, making it a David versus Goliath scenario for many policyholders.

Because of these challenges, hiring an experienced lawyer is essential for:

  • Evaluating if bad faith occurred.
  • Gathering evidence.
  • Navigating negotiations or litigation.
  • Advocating for full compensation.

Initial Client Consultation and Case Evaluation

When a policyholder suspects bad faith, the first step is usually to consult a lawyer who specializes in insurance disputes. During this meeting, the lawyer:

  • Reviews the insurance policy details.
  • Examines all correspondence and documents related to the claim.
  • Listens to the client’s experience with the insurance company.
  • Identifies any potential violations of good faith.
  • Advises on the merits of pursuing a bad faith claim.

A thorough evaluation helps set realistic expectations and formulate a strategy.

Investigating and Gathering Evidence

Building a strong bad faith case requires comprehensive evidence. Lawyers will typically:

  • Collect all claim-related documents, including denial letters, emails, and recorded calls.
  • Obtain the original insurance policy and any amendments.
  • Review the insurer’s claim handling procedures.
  • Interview witnesses, such as adjusters, experts, or contractors.
  • Retain experts to evaluate the value of the claim and the insurer’s conduct.
  • Investigate industry standards to establish if the insurer’s behavior deviated from accepted norms.

This phase is critical because courts require clear proof that the insurer acted unreasonably or in bad faith.

Demand and Negotiation

Before filing a lawsuit, lawyers often attempt to resolve the matter through negotiation or mediation. They will send a demand letter to the insurance company outlining:

  • The facts of the case.
  • The basis for the bad faith claim.
  • The damages the policyholder seeks.
  • A deadline for response.

Negotiations may involve settlement discussions, where the lawyer advocates for a fair resolution without the expense or time of litigation. Sometimes insurers agree to pay a reasonable amount to avoid legal proceedings.

Filing a Lawsuit

If negotiations fail, the lawyer files a lawsuit against the insurance company. This involves:

  • Drafting a complaint detailing the bad faith allegations.
  • Explaining how the insurer breached its duties.
  • Stating the damages suffered by the policyholder, such as unpaid claim amounts, emotional distress, and consequential losses.
  • Requesting compensatory and, in some cases, punitive damages to punish egregious behavior.

Discovery Process

After the lawsuit is filed, both sides engage in discovery—an exchange of information to uncover all relevant facts. Lawyers request:

  • Internal insurer documents and communications.
  • Claims manuals and training materials.
  • Emails and memos between adjusters and management.
  • Depositions of insurer representatives and experts.

Discovery can reveal the insurer’s mindset and help prove intentional misconduct or negligence.

Trial or Settlement

Most bad faith cases settle before trial. However, if no settlement is reached, the case proceeds to trial, where:

  • Lawyers present evidence and witness testimony.
  • They argue how the insurer’s conduct violated the duty of good faith.
  • A judge or jury decides if bad faith occurred and what damages should be awarded.

Experienced lawyers prepare clients for trial by managing expectations and developing compelling arguments.

Post-Trial and Appeals

If the verdict favors the policyholder, the insurer may appeal the decision. Lawyers continue to advocate during appeals to uphold the judgment or negotiate further settlements.

Additional Roles of Bad Faith Lawyers

Beyond litigation, bad faith lawyers also:

  • Educate policyholders about their rights.
  • Help clients avoid future disputes by reviewing policies before claims arise.
  • Collaborate with regulators or consumer protection agencies when appropriate.
  • Support class action lawsuits if multiple policyholders are affected.

Conclusion

Insurance bad faith cases are complex battles that require knowledge, persistence, and strategic advocacy. When an insurer refuses to honor a legitimate claim or treats a policyholder unfairly, lawyers step in to hold the company accountable and secure just compensation.

From the initial consultation through trial or settlement, lawyers carefully investigate, negotiate, and litigate to protect clients’ rights. If you suspect insurance bad faith, consulting an experienced attorney promptly can make all the difference in winning your case and restoring your peace of mind.

Read More: